Extemp Central

At this year’s National Catholic Forensic League (NCFL) Grand National Tournament #1 McKinley Paltzik of Phoenix Country Day School (AZ) won her second national championship and made history by becoming the second extemper in history to win a career grand slam. Paltzik won the tournament by four ranks over #8 Amy Cao of Ridge High School (NJ).

It is the first time that an extemper has won a career grand slam since 2005 when Kevin Troy of Eagan High School (MN) won the NCFL National Championship.

The win is Paltzik’s eighth of the season, which also sets a new record for wins in the National Points Race. The victory clinches the National Points Race title for Paltzik after she finished runner-up to Daniel Kind of Lake Highland Prepartory School (FL) last season.

While NCFL did not attract as many ranked extempers are other national competitions, those who did attend made deep runs in a tournament that featured 178 extempers. The final round also featured George Mason Patriot Games champion #9 Taylor Burris of the Potomac School (VA), who placed third, #13 Kevin Li of Ridge High School (NJ), who placed fourth, and #17 Aidan Marks of Benilde-St. Margaret’s (MN), who placed sixth and improved on a semi-finalist finish at the previous year’s national tournament.

Varun Nannuri of Shrewsbury High School (MA) rounded out the final round with a fifth place finish.

Judges in the final round were uniform in many of their ranks. Paltzik took four of the five available first place ranks while Cao took four of the five available second place ranks.

The final round also saw a three-way tie for third place between Burris, Li, and Nannuri. In cumulative scores, Burris beat Li by one rank to claim third overall.

Other notable finishes included a semi-finalist showing for #3 Theodore Gercken of the College Preparatory School (CA) and and octa-finalist placing for #21 Anastasia Koch of Eagan High School.

All of the quarter-finalists at the tournament earn a bid leg to the 2024 Extemp TOC at Northwestern University. All semi-finalists and finalists earn an automatic qualification to next year’s University of Kentucky TOC.

Here are the results of the 2023 National Catholic Forensic League Grand National Tournament (Click here for tab sheet):

Read More

1. Did Speaker McCarthy outmaneuver President Biden on debt ceiling negotiations?
2. Is U.S. consumer behavior becoming increasingly polarized along political lines?
3. How can Ron DeSantis capture the Republican presidential nomination?
4. Should the U.S. federal government regulate adolescent use of social media?
5. Is it too early for Congress to regulate the artificial intelligence industry?
6. What would a bipartisan reform of Social Security look like?
7. How will artificial intelligence affect future U.S. political campaigns?
8. Will the Texas Senate vote to remove Ken Paxton from office?
9. Does the U.S. have a dysfunctional foreign policy toward Turkey?
10. Will the debate over reparations split the Democratic Party’s diverse coalition?

1. Does the Durham Report bolster President Trump’s re-election effort?
2. Should New York City cease being a sanctuary city?
3. How will the need for critical minerals for electric cars shape U.S. foreign policy?
4. Should Democrats demand tax increases as part of a debt ceiling deal with Republicans?
5. Is JPMorgan Chase becoming too big?
6. Has the U.S. done enough to help schools recover the “learning loss” from COVID?
7. Will transgender rights be a major issue in the 2024 presidential election?
8. What can be done to bridge the growing urban-rural divide in politics?
9. Will Tim Scott’s presidential candidacy gain traction?
10. Which tech firm will be the biggest beneficiary of AI?

1. Was the CNN town hall a success for former President Trump?
2. Will increased border crossings provide new momentum for immigration reform?
3. Is the Biden re-election effort stumbling out of the gates?
4. Should the U.S. provide greater incentives for green energy companies to relocate their operations from China?
5. Is white supremacy the biggest terrorist threat that faces the United States?
6. How should drone technology be used by the U.S. military as it prepares for the next war?
7. Should U.S. airlines be forced to pay passengers for delays?
8. Does President Biden have the constitutional authority to ignore the debt ceiling?
9. Should Democrats schedule primary debates for 2024?
10. Does the U.S. need to loosen its securtiy-clearance process?

Last weekend, the second major tournament of the 2022-2023, the Tournament of Champions of Extemporaneous Speaking, took place at Northwestern University. 45 extempers made the trip to Evanston, Illinois for the event.

#1 McKinley Paltzik of Phoenix Country Day School (AZ) continued to put together the most dominanting season the circuit has seen in 18 years, winning her fourth major championship by five ranks over #6 Gabriel Bo of Plano West Senior High School (TX). It marks Paltzik’s seventh National Points Race win of the year, tying the record set in last year’s competition by Daniel Kind of Lake Highland Preparatory School (FL).

The victory is Paltzik’s third consecutive major victory, a streak that goes back to winning last year’s National Speech and Debate Association (NSDA) national championship in International Extemp. It puts her in elite company as only four extempers in history have won four or more major titles. She is the first extemper to win the first two legs of the grand slam since Jacqueline Wei of Plano West, who did so during the 2018-2019 season.

The only major title that Paltzik has yet to win is the National Catholic Forensic League (NCFL) National Championship. If she were to win that, she would become only the second extemper in history to win a career grand slam, something that the circuit has not seen since Kevin Troy of Eagan High School (MN) accomplished the feat in 2005.

While Paltzik took three first place ranks in the final round, the other four first place ranks were dispersed to two other competitors. #5 Phoena Lin of Plano West took two first place ranks and finished third overall, one rank behind teammate Bo. Aidan Marks of Benilde-St. Margaret’s (MN) took the other two available first place ranks and finished fourth, one rank behind Lin.

#3 Sruti Peddi of BASIS Scottsdale (AZ) finished fifth, the only competitor to reach the final round of both TOC competitons this season. And #7 Taylor Burris of the Potomac School (VA) was the sixth place finisher.

All of the finalists except for Marks have reached three or more National Points Race final rounds this season. Paltzik was making her seventh final round appearance; Peddi was making her sixth; and Bo, Lin, and Burris were making their fourth.

University of Kentucky Tournament of Champions (TOC) winner #12 Pierce McDade of the University School (IL) missed out on a chance of a TOC double-up after dropping in semi-finals. Other notables who were eliminated in semi-finals included #2 Theodore Gercken of the College Preparatory School (CA) and #24 Katherine Lee of Plano West.

Northwestern University also awards a sweepstakes trophy to the best performing team at the tournament. This was won by Plano West, who had 25% of the semi-finalists at the event. The Potomac School was second and Phoenix Country Day was third.

Since the Extemp TOC counts as a third tier event, all competitors who reached elimination rounds will receive National Points Race points.

Here are the results of the 2023 Extemp TOC at Northwestern University (Click here for tab sheet):

Read More

Editor’s Note: Preparing students for AP testing led to the delay of this write up. Our write up of the Extemp TOC will follow on Thursday and there will be an update to the National Points Race by early next week.

A few weeks ago, the University of Kentucky hosted its annual Tournament of Champions (TOC) event. 74 extempers converged on Lexington, Kentucky for the third tier event, which was narrowly won by #12 Pierce McDade of the University School (IL).

McDade won his first National Points Race event, and the first event of the post-season, by one rank over #17 Gordy Sun of the Harker School (CA) and two ranks over #3 Sruti Peddi of BASIS Scottsdale (AZ) and #8 Amy Cao of Ridge High School (NJ).

The five judges in the final round split their first place ranks across five different competitors and Cao almost won the tournament without taking any of them. In the end, an errant six did not cost McDade the tournament as Sun and Peddi’s chances of winning the title were dashed by a sixth place rank in their final round score.

Peddi and Cao tied for third place, but Peddi won a judges preference tiebreaker 3-2 for her fourth top three finish of the season.

Fifth place was won by Sumedh Seetharam of Scottsdale Preparatory Academy (AZ), who finished two ranks behind Cao and two ahead of California Invitational winner, #9 Rohit Vakkalagadda of Bellarmine College Preparatory (CA).

#10 Charlotte Reitman of the University School (FL) and #14 Kevin Li of Ridge dropped in the semi-final round. Other ranked competitors dropped in quarter-finals. These included #2 Theodore Gercken of the College Preparatory School (CA), #7 Taylor Burris of the Potomac School (VA), #13 Isaiah Sohn of Redlands High School (CA), #18 Tyler Crivella of Seven Lakes High School (TX), and #20 Anastasia Koch of Eagan High School (MN).

This year’s TOC is the first to be awarded third tier points in the National Points Race. McDade will receive 100 points for his victory while all competitors who reached elimination rounds will earn points.

Here were the results of the 2023 University of Kentucky Tournament of Champions (Click here for tab sheet):

Read More